StaylyGo Pick Cozy Boutique Charm Steps from Sarasota Bay Coffee Shop & Wine Bar
Hotel Cafe Coffee Shop
The Reserve Retreat
Experience polished boutique comfort at The Reserve Retreat in Sarasota. Enjoy an authentic Italian restaurant, cozy rooms, and an LGBTQ+ friendly atmosphere near Sarasota Bay and local attractions.
1322 N Tamiami Trl, Sarasota, FL 34236, United States4.5/5 (566 reviews)
The Reserve Retreat is a polished boutique hotel nestled in a quaint home along Highway 41, just a five-minute walk from the serene Sarasota Bay. This distinctive hotel blends historic charm with modern comforts, offering a warm, inviting environment enriched by its authentic Italian restaurant, an intimate coffee shop, and a cozy wine bar.
Designed to welcome a diverse crowd, The Reserve Retreat is proudly LGBTQ+ friendly, creating a genuine sense of belonging and openness. Its location places guests within easy reach of cultural treasures such as the John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art, only three miles away, and other vibrant local attractions.
Each accommodation exudes character with classic details and a comfortable atmosphere, where quiet charm meets thoughtful touches. The on-site dining options, including The Reserve Restaurant by Chef Antonio, serve authentic Sicilian cuisine that delights guests looking for a memorable meal steps from their room. The overall experience offers a blend of relaxation, cultural proximity, and heartfelt hospitality for travelers seeking more than just a place to stay.
LGBTQ+ friendly atmosphere Steps from Sarasota Bay On-site coffee shop & wine bar Welcoming boutique elegance
What makes this stay special
A few reasons this stay stands out from the others.
Authentic Italian dining
The Reserve Restaurant by Chef Antonio offers an exquisite Sicilian culinary journey, blending rustic flavors with a cozy, elegant setting just downstairs.
Historic boutique charm
Set in a quaint, vintage home, the hotel balances classic architectural details with modern comfort for a timeless, inviting stay.
Inclusive & welcoming
LGBTQ+ friendly ambiance and attentive staff foster a genuine sense of community and belonging for all guests.
Prime cultural location
Close to Sarasota's arts and nature highlights, including the Ringling Museum and botanical gardens, perfect for enriching outings.
Amenities that matter
A full view of what's available — and what's not — so you can decide with confidence.
Free Wi-Fi
Paid breakfast
Free parking
Air-conditioned
Pet-friendly
Kid-friendly
Restaurant
Bar
Smoke-free
Accessible
Pool
Business center
Airport shuttle
Fitness center
Room photos
A look at the rooms you'll find at this stay.
Location and nearby places
Explore top attractions, convenient transport, and local gems near The Reserve Retreat.
The John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art3 miles away
Marie Selby Botanical Gardens Downtown Sarasota5 minutes by car
Sarasota Bay (walking distance)5 minutes walk
Mote Marine Laboratory6 miles away
Sarasota Bradenton International Airport10 min by car
Tampa International Airport~1 hour by car
St. Pete–Clearwater International Airport1 hour by car
Us 41/14th St Transit Stop1 min walk
N Tamiami Trl @ 15th St Transit Stop1 min walk
Cocoanut Ave @ 13th St Transit Stop4 min walk
The Reserve Retreat offers easy access to downtown Sarasota’s cultural sites and airports, with notable attractions and convenient local transit within walking distance.
What the stay feels like
A short editorial tour through a typical day at Ocean View Resort.
Morning
Wake up beneath softly sunlit ceilings, then savor freshly brewed coffee in an inviting café setting, infused with the aroma of roasted beans and quiet anticipation.
Afternoon
Step outside for a stroll toward Sarasota Bay or explore nearby galleries and botanical gardens, returning to the cool shade of the hotel’s terrace restaurant.
Evening
Dine in the intimate Italian restaurant where the clink of wine glasses and rich Sicilian flavors create a warm, welcoming ambiance beneath historic walls.
Traveler reviews
What recent guests say about their stay.
4.5
566 reviews
5
422
4
85
3
36
2
17
1
18
C
Chris Moreno
May 14, 2026
"We loved our stay here and plan to return soon. The room was just perfect and meal at the Italian restaurant was incredible. We plan to return soon!"
M
madi liljeberg
May 08, 2026
"Wonderful stay with a beautiful room. Very easy checkin and checkout instructions. The Italian restaurant downstairs was also lovely for dinner!"
M
McKenzie Koval
May 02, 2026
"We booked this location for our 4 year anniversary. What drew us was the quaint building/outdoor architecture and dog friendly-ness! This was a slightly last minute, week of, booking, but the owners shared all the important information. We utilized this location for Selby Botanical Gardens Christmas Lights (highly recommend that as well). We were unable to utilize The Reserve Retreat onsite coffee shop or restaurant due to previous plans but thought having these dining options were a great idea! They..."
M
M Brown
Apr 30, 2026
"From the moment we arrived at The Reserve Retreat Boutique Hotel in Sarasota, we were charmed by its quaint, old-school elegance and genuine hospitality. This hidden gem combines timeless charm with comfortable, thoughtful touches that made our stay truly memorable. The accommodations felt like a beautiful step back in time—our room had classic details that created a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Everything was spotless and comfortable, with just the right balance of antique flair. It’s rare to find a place that..."
R
Roger Ghazali
Apr 07, 2026
"Beautiful historic mansion with rustic/modern touch. Features a 5 star cozy Authentic Italian restaurant down stairs. The food is absolutely delicious and always packed. Book while there’s availability cause the rooms book fast. THIS IS THE RINGLINGS PRIMARY HOME BEFORE THEY GOT PAID HAHA. Yana/Rachelle/Antonio are take you in a dive into Italy as soon as you walk in. I mean it’s really walking into Italy. The food, the servers, the wine, the desert, the bread, the salad, & champagne..."
S
Stacey Brown
Mar 01, 2026
"My wife and I had a wonderful stay at the Reserve Retreat. The accommodations were charming and full of quaint, old-school character, creating a cozy and relaxing atmosphere. The on-site café was a standout—delicious food, great coffee, and caring staff. I would highly recommend, and will definitely stay again."
K
Karen Reese
Feb 06, 2026
"This is a charming family-owned inn, with rustic rooms. I felt very welcome by a beautiful person named Sol. The room was clean and comfortable. I could hear the street traffic from my room. But it became quiet after 11:00. I recommend this place for solo travelers or couples."
B
Boris Covic
Feb 02, 2026
"Cozy and charming place, authentic, with historic feel. Good affordable stay, with soul. The only downside is the internet if you need it for work, kinda slow and unreliable, so pack some mobile data if you need to be working. The rest of the stuff is as promoted."
Frequently asked questions
Quick answers to things travelers often ask about this stay.
Check-in is from 15:00 and check-out is until 11:00.
Yes, it features THE RESERVE RESTAURANT by CHEF ANTONIO offering authentic Italian cuisine, as well as a café and coffee shop.
Yes, the hotel is LGBTQ+ friendly.
The hotel is a 5-minute walk from Sarasota Bay and about 3 miles from The John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art.
Sarasota Bradenton International Airport is approximately 10 minutes by car.
Yes, several transit stops are within a 1 to 4 minute walk from the hotel.
The hotel is noted for being dog friendly, according to guest reviews.
You may also like
Similar stays you may like
More inspiring stays curated for travelers like you.
Boutique
4.2 (1,400)
Snow Creek Ski Area
1 Snow Creek Dr, Weston, MO 64098, United States
Boutique
4.5 (583)
The North Hero House Inn & Restaurant
3643 US-2, North Hero, VT 05474, United States
Boutique
4.6 (89)
Mt. Itasca Winter Sports Center
200 Mount Itasca Dr, Coleraine, MN 55722, United States
Boutique
4.8 (162)
Jackson Ski Touring Foundation Nordic Ski Area
153 Main St, Jackson, NH 03846, United States
For hosts & hotels
Want your hotel featured on StaylyGo?
Reach travelers looking for inspiring and well-matched stays.
